Bigger list. Better open rates.
In under a month, Retention.com grew American Thinker’s list by 25%, and it’s opening at over 40%.
- Publication
- American Thinker
- Email platform
- Mailchimp
- With Retention.com since
- September 2026
- Interviewed
- Ivan Delgado Calderon, Digital & Business Operations Advisor
The quarter they cut, replaced within a month
American Thinker started by cutting. Anyone who had not opened in six months came off the list, which took out about a quarter of it and lifted the open rate over 40%. The question was whether that could survive growing the list back.
The risk was in what came next. A cleaned list starts shrinking the day you finish it, and refilling it quickly is how the open rate ends up back where it started. American Thinker switched on Retention.com instead, and set the strictest collection thresholds we run on any account: five pages read, or four minutes on the site, before a reader counts as interested at all.
Within a month, the quarter they cut had been fully replaced by readers Retention.com identified on the site, and the open rate actually improved. More than 70% of those readers are still actively engaging on the list.
The readers Retention.com put back are opening at over 40%, the same rate as the subscribers who survived the cut.
We were wasting money sending to people who weren’t reading us. Cutting them was the easy part. Within a month, with the help of Retention.com, we’re back up to the same size and the open rate is at 40%.
